It's tempting to start changing everything: new creative, different targeting, a redesigned product page, a new offer, checkout changes, more emails.
Don't open Pandora's Box yet.
First, figure out where the problem actually starts. These three checks can help you determine whether you have a traffic problem, an onsite problem, a conversion problem—or whether the customers you're acquiring simply aren't valuable enough to justify more spend.
Key takeaway: Don't start by fixing everything. Find the first place the data tells you something isn't working.
1. Compare the Traffic That Converts to the Traffic That Doesn't
Start with the data you already have.
Instead of looking at one overall conversion rate, break it apart and look for the outlier.
Pull the last 60–90 days and compare:
-
Mobile vs. desktop
-
New vs. returning visitors
-
Paid vs. organic traffic
-
Meta vs. Google vs. other sources
-
Campaigns and audiences
-
Top landing pages
-
Products or services
-
Add to cart or lead → checkout/booking → purchase
You're not trying to become a data scientist. You're looking for the first obvious difference.
Example: If desktop converts at 3% and mobile converts at 0.8%, I wouldn't start by rewriting every ad.
I'd pick up my phone.
If people are adding to cart but aren't completing checkout, that's another clue. If a service business is generating plenty of form starts but very few completed forms, that's a clue too.
Find where behavior changes before deciding what needs to change.
If the problem appears to start with paid traffic, go deeper with Why Your Ads Aren't Working. If visitors are arriving but struggling to find answers or take the next step, start with Onsite UX: Fix the Top 3 Pages First. Those articles address those specific parts of the Journey rather than trying to fix everything at once. (eCom Karma)
Quick win: Write down the three biggest differences you see in your conversion data. Don't fix them yet. First, look for the pattern.
2. Become Your Own Customer
Analytics can show you where people stop. They can't always tell you why.
So do something incredibly simple:
Buy your own product or become a lead for your own service.
Do it on your phone. Don't use an admin login or skip steps because you already know how your website works.
If you sell products:
-
Find the product.
-
Choose an option.
-
Add it to cart.
-
Find the shipping cost.
-
Look for the return policy.
-
Try your preferred payment method.
-
Complete checkout.
If you sell services:
-
Find the service.
-
Look for pricing or next steps.
-
Fill out the form.
-
Book the appointment if available.
-
Use chat.
-
Read the confirmation.
-
See what happens next.
Then ask someone who doesn't work for the company to do the same thing while you watch.
And don't help them.
Watch where they hesitate.
Maybe shipping is a surprise. Apple Pay isn't available. The form asks for 12 things when you need four. They're forced to create an account. They can't find a return policy. They don't know what happens after submitting a form. They click something you never expected them to click.
Those seemingly small details can create real friction.
If customers want what you're selling but the process is getting in their way, go deeper into Conversion Flow: The Guide to Getting the Yes. For products and services, the goal of Conversion Flow is the same: make it easy to pay, book or confidently raise a hand. (eCom Karma)
Karma lens: A website can be technically working and still be surprisingly difficult to buy from.
3. Follow the Conversion All the Way to Revenue
Now take the analysis one step further.
Don't stop at the conversion.
For a product business, look at:
First Purchase → Delivery → Return/Refund → Second Purchase
For a service business:
Lead → Qualified Lead → Appointment → Proposal/Estimate → Closed Customer
This can completely change how you evaluate marketing.
Imagine one campaign produces leads for $40 and another produces them for $90.
The $40 campaign looks like the winner.
But what if almost none of those $40 leads become customers, while 25% of the $90 leads close?
Same with products.
A campaign generating inexpensive first orders isn't necessarily your best source if those customers only buy with a steep discount, have a high return rate or never purchase again.
Look at:
-
Cost to acquire the customer or lead
-
Actual closed revenue
-
Refunds and returns
-
First-order profitability
-
Lead-to-customer close rate
-
Repeat purchase rate
-
Time to second purchase
Follow the money, not just the platform metric.
If customers convert once but the relationship stops there, that's a different problem. Read Follow-Up: Reduce "What Happens Next?" Messages and Build LTV. Follow-Up is Step 5 because the customer journey continues after someone buys, books or contacts you. (eCom Karma)
Reality check: A conversion tells you someone took an action. Revenue and customer value tell you whether that action was worth paying for.
Three Checks Before You Change Everything
When conversions aren't where you want them, don't immediately change your ads, website, offer, checkout and email flows at the same time.
Start here:
1. Compare it.
Find where the traffic that converts behaves differently from the traffic that doesn't.
2. Experience it.
Go through your own customer journey—and have someone else do it while you watch.
3. Follow it.
Track the conversion through to actual revenue, profitability and, when applicable, the next purchase.
Then decide what needs attention.
Your customer journey is still:
Discovery → Brand Research → Onsite UX → Conversion Flow → Follow-Up
You don't need to fix all five at once. You need to identify which one is keeping the next customer from moving forward.
For more on why improving the right stage matters before simply adding traffic, read More Revenue. More Profit. Same Traffic.. (eCom Karma)
Book a Karma Call and let's find the next best move before you open Pandora's Box.
